EDITION The Reykjavik EDITION
The only proper 5-star address in Reykjavík, and it knows it. The Reykjavik EDITION sits harborside next to Harpa — part Ian Schrager polish, part Nordic restraint, with a Michelin-listed restaurant, an underground hammam, and a rooftop bar that doubles as the city's best Northern Lights perch. In a city where the competitive set is mostly Hiltons, Konsulat, and Canopy, The Reykjavik EDITION is largely uncontested at this tier — which is both its advantage and its problem.
Couples on a milestone trip, honeymooners, and design-minded travelers who want the best address in Reykjavík as a base for Golden Circle day trips and Northern Lights hunting. Also strong for anyone who values a genuinely excellent hotel restaurant and spa on property after long days outdoors.
You expect Four Seasons or Ritz-Carlton levels of intuitive, consistent service — the delivery here is too uneven for guests accustomed to that tier. Also skip it if you need bright, airy rooms with real storage, or if opaque resort-style fees genuinely ruin a stay.
Inconsistent, and that's the central issue. At its best — Kevin, Joy, Morgan, Marino, Lidiane get named constantly — the team is genuinely warm and goes well beyond the brief. At its worst, check-in devolves into hours-long waits for rooms that were supposedly "almost ready," housekeeping skips turndown, and basics like toilet paper or tissues go unreplenished.
Tides is the strength — near-Michelin cooking, strong wine list, excellent lamb and seafood. Breakfast splits opinion: the buffet is broad and fresh for most, thin and dry for others. Service at Tides runs slow, sometimes egregiously so (90-minute waits aren't rare).
Beautifully designed but compact, and notably dark — a recurring complaint in winter when rooms feel dim rather than moody. Heated bathroom floors, Le Labo amenities, comfortable beds, and floor-to-ceiling harbor views are the highlights. Storage is genuinely inadequate: no dressers, curtain-fronted closets, luggage on the floor.
The standout. Directly on the old harbor, next to Harpa, walking distance to Laugavegur shopping, restaurants, and tour pickup at bus stop 5. Quiet at night despite the central position.
Contentious. Rooms run $700–$1,500+, the mandatory 7,000 ISK daily destination fee rankles nearly everyone (it only applies against F&B, doesn't roll over), and valet is extra. Guests paying full rack expect more polish than they consistently receive.
Moody, dark wood, volcanic-inspired, signature Le Labo scent throughout. The lobby bar with its circular fireplace is the social heart; the rooftop and Tolt speakeasy add range. Love-it-or-hate-it aesthetic — some find it sophisticated, others find it gloomy.
Inconsistent, and that's the central issue. At its best — Kevin, Joy, Morgan, Marino, Lidiane get named constantly — the team is genuinely warm and goes well beyond the brief. At its worst, check-in devolves into hours-long waits for rooms that were supposedly "almost ready," housekeeping skips turndown, and basics like toilet paper or tissues go unreplenished.
Tides is the strength — near-Michelin cooking, strong wine list, excellent lamb and seafood. Breakfast splits opinion: the buffet is broad and fresh for most, thin and dry for others. Service at Tides runs slow, sometimes egregiously so (90-minute waits aren't rare).
Beautifully designed but compact, and notably dark — a recurring complaint in winter when rooms feel dim rather than moody. Heated bathroom floors, Le Labo amenities, comfortable beds, and floor-to-ceiling harbor views are the highlights. Storage is genuinely inadequate: no dressers, curtain-fronted closets, luggage on the floor.
The standout. Directly on the old harbor, next to Harpa, walking distance to Laugavegur shopping, restaurants, and tour pickup at bus stop 5. Quiet at night despite the central position.
Contentious. Rooms run $700–$1,500+, the mandatory 7,000 ISK daily destination fee rankles nearly everyone (it only applies against F&B, doesn't roll over), and valet is extra. Guests paying full rack expect more polish than they consistently receive.
Moody, dark wood, volcanic-inspired, signature Le Labo scent throughout. The lobby bar with its circular fireplace is the social heart; the rooftop and Tolt speakeasy add range. Love-it-or-hate-it aesthetic — some find it sophisticated, others find it gloomy.
- Interactive dashboard
- 365 days of nightly rates
- Day × month heatmap
- All 6 per-category reviews
- All 5 strengths & weaknesses
- Compare up to 6 hotels