AUBERGE Madeline Hotel and Residences, Auberge Collection
Ski-in/ski-out at the foot of Telluride's Mountain Village lifts, with the free gondola to downtown Telluride a short walk away — this is the Madeline Hotel and Residences, Auberge Collection's core pitch, and for many guests it's enough on its own. The property mixes traditional hotel rooms with privately-owned residences under Auberge management. Until the announced Four Seasons opens nearby, luxury hotels in Telluride's Mountain Village have no direct five-star peer, so the Madeline's main competition is the town's Element 52 and higher-end rentals.
Ski families and couples who prioritize slope access above all else — the ski valet and lift proximity at the Madeline Hotel and Residences, Auberge Collection are genuinely class-leading. Also strong for dog owners, milestone anniversaries, and multi-generational groups booking a residence with a kitchen and washer/dryer.
You expect flawless Forbes five-star service and dining as part of the deal — operational misses are too frequent here. Also skip it if you need reliable in-room WiFi for work, or if a proper full-service spa with sauna and relaxation lounge is central to your trip.
Genuinely warm and personal on good days, visibly strained on bad ones. When it works — and it usually does — staff remember names, fuss over kids and dogs, and deliver thoughtful turndown gifts, handwritten notes, and milestone touches. When it fails, the pattern is consistent: unanswered phones, missed turndown, botched special requests, and slow follow-through from management.
The weakest category and the most frequent complaint. Black Iron Kitchen and the Timber Room bar look the part and occasionally deliver, but slow service, confusing portion sizes, cold room-service deliveries, and $90-plus breakfasts for two recur across years. Many guests end up dining in Telluride town via the gondola.
Inconsistent. Renovated rooms and larger residences are genuinely luxurious — spacious bathrooms, heated floors, Nespresso, humidifiers, thoughtful altitude amenities. Unrenovated rooms feel dated, with stained carpets, dim lighting, and tight layouts. Residences vary widely because individual owners control finishes.
Unbeatable and the single strongest reason to book. The ski valet sits steps from Chair 10, the free gondola to Telluride town runs until midnight, and the ice rink, restaurants, and shops of Mountain Village plaza are immediately outside.
Contested. At $1,000-plus nightly rates plus resort and parking fees, service and food misses sting. Guests who get a renovated room, attentive service, and good weather feel it's worth it; those who hit operational stumbles do not.
Warmly done alpine-modern with fireplaces, a handsome bar, shuffleboard, and cozy lobby nooks. The rooftop pool and hot tubs with mountain views are a genuine highlight. Dog-friendly without feeling like a kennel.
Genuinely warm and personal on good days, visibly strained on bad ones. When it works — and it usually does — staff remember names, fuss over kids and dogs, and deliver thoughtful turndown gifts, handwritten notes, and milestone touches. When it fails, the pattern is consistent: unanswered phones, missed turndown, botched special requests, and slow follow-through from management.
The weakest category and the most frequent complaint. Black Iron Kitchen and the Timber Room bar look the part and occasionally deliver, but slow service, confusing portion sizes, cold room-service deliveries, and $90-plus breakfasts for two recur across years. Many guests end up dining in Telluride town via the gondola.
Inconsistent. Renovated rooms and larger residences are genuinely luxurious — spacious bathrooms, heated floors, Nespresso, humidifiers, thoughtful altitude amenities. Unrenovated rooms feel dated, with stained carpets, dim lighting, and tight layouts. Residences vary widely because individual owners control finishes.
Unbeatable and the single strongest reason to book. The ski valet sits steps from Chair 10, the free gondola to Telluride town runs until midnight, and the ice rink, restaurants, and shops of Mountain Village plaza are immediately outside.
Contested. At $1,000-plus nightly rates plus resort and parking fees, service and food misses sting. Guests who get a renovated room, attentive service, and good weather feel it's worth it; those who hit operational stumbles do not.
Warmly done alpine-modern with fireplaces, a handsome bar, shuffleboard, and cozy lobby nooks. The rooftop pool and hot tubs with mountain views are a genuine highlight. Dog-friendly without feeling like a kennel.
- Interactive dashboard
- 365 days of nightly rates
- Day × month heatmap
- All 6 per-category reviews
- All 5 strengths & weaknesses
- Compare up to 6 hotels