The Witchery
Daily price line
Upcoming nightly rates
Review
Character and identity
Tucked into the medieval close at the top of the Royal Mile, steps from Edinburgh Castle, The Witchery occupies a 16th-century merchant's house you could walk past without noticing. Inside, the register is Gothic theatre: candlelit rooms, oak panelling, velvet drapery, painted ceilings, antique furniture staged like a stately home set piece. The property is tiny at just nine suites, with the celebrated restaurant downstairs serving seasonal Scottish produce through a French lens in a red-leather banquetted dining room, plus a Secret Garden terrace for warmer months. Service is warm and unfussy, attentive without ceremony.
Who's it for
Best for:
Couples after a romantic, theatrical bolt-hole, groups of friends celebrating a milestone, and anyone who finds maximalist period drama more appealing than minimalist design. Food-led travellers will be especially well served, and the central but hidden setting suits guests who want Old Town atmosphere without the Royal Mile crowds at their door.
Should look elsewhere:
Families (it's adults-only, with no kids' menu in the restaurant), wellness-focused travellers who want a gym and spa, and anyone needing communal lounges, easy parking, or contemporary hotel infrastructure. Design literates drawn to clean, modern interiors will find the aesthetic too operatic.
Bottom line
What you're paying for here is atmosphere and a sense of occasion that no purpose-built hotel in Edinburgh can match: nine suites, candlelight, and a kitchen that genuinely earns its reputation. Book the Library or Heriot Suite for the full effect, reserve months ahead around Festival season or Hogmanay, and treat the £40 tasting menu as part of the stay rather than an add-on.
Images
Location
Nearby tracked hotels
10 nearest