Best-value hotels in New York with pool

The Rockaway Hotel

New York · United States

Nightly rate $231–$655

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.5

The Lake House on Canandaigua

New York · United States

Nightly rate $246–$765

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.3

TWA Hotel

New York · United States

Nightly rate $253–$788

CN Readers' Choice '23 Google 4.2

The Otesaga Resort Hotel

New York · United States

Nightly rate $381–$512

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.6

Whiteface Lodge

New York · United States

Nightly rate $224–$8,840

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.6

Virgin Hotels New York City

New York · United States

Nightly rate $251–$1,128

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 3.9

Canoe Place Inn & Cottages

New York · United States

Nightly rate $418–$1,282

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.7

Scribner's Catskill Lodge

New York · United States

Nightly rate $302–$502

CN Readers' Choice '17 Google 4.4

Gansevoort Meatpacking NYC

New York · United States

Nightly rate $374–$1,318

CN Readers' Choice '24 Google 4.2

Troutbeck

New York · United States

Nightly rate $590–$3,535

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.6

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge

New York · United States

Nightly rate $394–$1,596

CN Hot List '18 Google 4.3

Gurney’s Montauk

New York · United States

Nightly rate $378–$1,996

CN Readers' Choice '25 Google 4.1

Inness

New York · United States

Nightly rate $648–$1,367

CN Hot List '22 Google 4.4

Maker Hotel

New York · United States

Nightly rate $518–$1,188

CN Hot List '21 Google 4.3

Wildflower Farms, Auberge Collection

New York · United States

Nightly rate $1,044–$3,992

CN Hot List '23 Google 4.6

Cheapest

The cheapest luxury hotel in New York is Urban Cowboy Lodge.

Median nightly$214Overall57

Best value

The best-value luxury hotel in New York is The Rockaway Hotel.

Median nightly$292Overall71

Highest rated

The highest rated luxury hotel in New York is Wildflower Farms, Auberge Collection.

Median nightly$1,624Overall76

Most expensive

The most expensive luxury hotel in New York is Wildflower Farms, Auberge Collection.

Median nightly$1,624Overall76

#	Property	Place	Overall	Min nightly	Median	Max
	x		–

Join to unlock →